Jeanine Pirro Called Out the Scheme Mamdani Is Using to Force Judges to Release Career Criminals

Kivanc Ekinci via Shutterstock

NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani spent last summer watching World Cup soccer with convicted prisoners at Rikers Island.

Now he wants to slash the jail population by more than 30 percent and turn the island into a "climate sustainability" park.

Jeanine Pirro just exposed the hidden mechanism that makes the whole scheme work.

Mamdani's Rikers Island Closure Plan Would Put 2100 Inmates Back on NYC Streets

New York City's self-described Democratic Socialist mayor unveiled his plan Friday to shut Rikers Island – the city's largest jail complex – down by 2032.

The complex currently holds about 6,600 people.

The four smaller "borough-based" facilities replacing it will hold only 4,500.

It's a plan to release roughly 2,100 people who are supposed to be behind bars.

Mayor Zoharn Mamdani – a card-carrying member of the Democratic Socialists of America, the same organization as AOC – wants to pull this off through early release programs and electronic monitoring bracelets.

Mamdani plans to convert Rikers itself into what he's calling "climate and sustainability projects."

Appearing on Fox News' The Ingraham Angle, Jeanine Pirro – Trump's U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia – cut through the green-energy pitch.

"I can't speak to the nonsense of climate sustainability," she told host Laura Ingraham. "I don't really give a damn, and nor does any defendant incarcerated give a damn about climate sustainability."

NYC Bail Reform Spiked Crime 20 Percent in 2019 and Mamdani Is Running the Same Play

Artificially shrinking jail capacity doesn't just mean fewer prisoners.

It means judges lose the authority to detain defendants they would otherwise lock up.

Pirro explained exactly how the trap is set: "They've already admitted there's something like a 30% drop in terms of the ability to house defendants. What does that tell you? That tells you that the whole socialist agenda is to not have accountability or consequences."

She went straight to the legal authority question: "That is a decision for a judge and a jury. It has nothing to do, nor should it have anything to do, with the amount of jail cells available."

That's the whole con.

Democrats can't abolish incarceration outright – the backlash would be instant and catastrophic.

So they cap the bed count and let the math do the dirty work.

Judges get blamed for "overcrowding" while Mamdani gets to claim he's just managing infrastructure.

New York City has tried to close Rikers before – under Koch in the 1970s, under Bloomberg in the 2000s, and under de Blasio, who promised it in 2017 and set a legally mandated 2027 deadline.

That deadline came and went.

Now Mamdani is sliding the deadline to 2032, while the jail is already under federal oversight for conditions so dangerous that a court considered stripping the city of control entirely.

The pattern never changes, and Pirro recognized it the moment Mamdani announced the plan.

"Make no mistake," she said. "If you've got someone who's being sent to jail, chances are they've had 2 or 3 incidents before they're being sent. There's been an incredible effort to keep them out of jail."

Pirro named the Left's real goal in one sentence: "This is all about the left's idea of rehabilitation instead of incarceration, punishment and deterrence."

The Manhattan Institute documented exactly what happened the last time New York Democrats ran this experiment: bail reform released roughly 2,000 career criminals from city jails in 2019, and crime spiked 20 percent within months. That wasn't a coincidence.

Mamdani now wants to run that experiment again at a larger scale – this time dressed up as a climate project.

It's camouflage.

A judge doesn't set bail based on how many solar panels fit on a waterfront.

Mamdani is trying to make available cell count – not judicial authority – the deciding factor in who walks free in New York City.

The Bronx neighborhoods where those 2,100 extra people end up didn't vote for that.

Pirro spent decades as a prosecutor and a judge watching this exact playbook unfold – and Friday night, she named it in front of millions.

The judges didn't vote to empty Rikers. If Mamdani gets away with it, every Democrat-run city does this next.

Sources:

  • Jim Hoft, "U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro TORCHES Socialist Mayor Mamdani's Plan to Shut Down Rikers Island and Slash Jail Population by Nearly 40% for 'Climate Sustainability,'" The Gateway Pundit, November 21, 2026.
  • Jim Quinn, "More Criminals, More Crime: Measuring the Public Safety Impact of New York's 2019 Bail Law," Manhattan Institute, July 28, 2022.
  • Peter D'Abrosca and Hannah Brennan, "Mamdani sparks fierce backlash for World Cup stunt 'palling around' with Rikers Island convicts," Fox News, July 16, 2026.