Mollie Hemingway Said John Thune Keeping His Job Showed Contempt for Republican Voters

Sviatlana Zyhmantovic via Shutterstock

Senate Republicans lost Texas, Kansas, and South Carolina in the midterm election.

John Thune looked into the camera and asked what he could have done differently.

And Mollie Hemingway had a brutal reaction to Thune keeping his job as GOP leader.

John Thune Reelected Senate Minority Leader One Week After Republicans Lost Texas

Senate Republicans reelected John Thune as their leader one week after losing Texas, Kansas, and South Carolina and surrendering the majority they had held for two years.

No one challenged him, and when 31 senators voted to hold elections immediately rather than take a week to ask what went wrong, Thune walked out of the closed-door meeting with his job intact and John Barrasso and Tom Cotton keeping their leadership posts beside him.

The Federalist’s Mollie Hemingway went on Fox News’ Special Report with Bret Baier and told him that putting back the same leaders who spent two years failing to deliver on the agenda voters sent them to accomplish "really showed contempt for the voters."

Speaker of the House Mike Johnson – a man nobody blamed for last Tuesday's losses – had already announced he would not seek House leadership. Johnson stepped aside. Thune ran to keep his job.

Bret Baier had asked Thune the night before about the 700 House-passed bills the Senate never voted on.

Thune said he didn't even know if the number was right, then asked: "What could we have done differently?"

Thune Killed the SAVE America Act and Now Democrats Have the Filibuster

Hemingway didn't leave Thune's question unanswered.

Republican voters wanted the Senate to secure the border, deal with Temporary Protected Status, overhaul the refugee system, fix the H-1B visa problem, codify Trump's executive orders into permanent law, and eliminate USAID for good.

None of it got done.

Donald Trump spent months demanding Thune nuke the 60-vote filibuster threshold and pass the SAVE America Act – the voter ID and proof-of-citizenship legislation the base and the White House treated as the top priority of the entire session.

Thune staged a "talking filibuster" exercise, watched Democrats block it, and called it a good-faith effort. Trump said publicly he "can't stand"

Republicans who refused this one move and warned Thune directly that Democrats would eliminate the filibuster the moment they had the votes.

Democrats now have the votes. South Dakota Republicans brought a censure resolution against Thune at their June state convention, calling his failure on the SAVE America Act his "most glaring" offense as majority leader. He ran for minority leader anyway.

What Hemingway Said About the Party's Survival

Before the vote, Hemingway posted on X that the Republican Party's survival may rest on Thune not being Senate minority leader and that the situation was "absolutely that dire."

Democrats went from 47 Senate seats to 56 – winning in Texas, South Carolina, and Alaska. They also just took Mississippi, where Cindy Hyde-Smith lost her seat to a Democrat in a state Trump won by nearly 23 points.

Senate terms are six years, and Republicans could be locked out of the Senate majority until 2032.

When only 15 senators voted to delay the leadership elections long enough to ask what went wrong, and 31 voted to give Thune the job immediately, the conference made clear it learned nothing from the night it lost Texas.

Thune Refused to Nuke the Filibuster and Now Democrats Have the Majority to Do It Themselves

Thune spent two years refusing to eliminate the 60-vote threshold that killed the SAVE America Act and every other Republican priority the base actually cared about.

Trump told him directly that Democrats would eliminate it themselves the moment they had the majority. Democrats now have 56 seats.

Chuck Schumer can nuke the rule that Thune spent two years protecting and pass his agenda with 51 votes, leaving Republicans no procedural tool to stop him if Democrats take the White House in 2028.

John Thune presided over one of the biggest GOP electoral disasters in history and is keeping his job.

Sources:

  • Mollie Hemingway, "Hemingway: Reelecting The Same Leadership That Had Done So Little 'Really Showed Contempt For Voters,'" RealClearPolitics/Fox News, November 11, 2026.
  • Staff, "Senate GOPs Elect John Thune Minority Leader Despite Electoral Losses," Breitbart, November 10, 2026.
  • Matt Vespa, "John Thune: I'm Not Sure That's Going to Resonate With the Base," Townhall, November 12, 2026.
  • Staff, "Thune Becomes MAGA's Midterm 'Fall Guy' With Voting Bill Crusade," Washington Examiner, March 16, 2026.
  • Staff, "Trump 'Disappointed' With Thune for Inaction on Filibuster and SAVE America Act," Fox News, May 2026.
  • Staff, "Pressed by Trump, Thune Still Has Support Where It Counts," National Review, 2026.